What breaks in India's government service apps: login, OTP and features that don't work
23% of Play Store reviews on India's top government service apps describe a malfunction, and every app had one on show. Login, OTP and broken features lead.
In this article
For a shopping app, a failed login is a lost sale. For a government service app, it's a person who can't download a document, renew a licence or reach a service they're entitled to, often with nowhere else to go.
This post covers the government services category of our India App Quality Report: 135 storefront reviews on 8 of India's most-used government apps, read on 23 October 2026.
The headline: every app had a malfunction review on show
23.0% of government app storefront reviews describe a malfunction (31 of 135; 95% range 16.7–30.7%), more than twice the 10.7% across all 187 apps.
- All 8 apps had at least one malfunction review on show.
- 64.6% of complaints are about the software, and only 16.7% about service, fees or support.
- None of the reviews described a failed payment. The problems are about getting in and getting things done.
- Half of the apps' latest release notes said only "bug fixes and improvements".
What breaks
| Malfunction | Government services | All 187 apps |
|---|---|---|
| A feature doesn't work | 7.4% | 3.3% |
| Login and OTP failures | 6.7% | 1.8% |
| Crashes, freezes, won't open | 5.2% | 2.3% |
| Wrong or stale data | 3.7% | 1.0% |
| Slow or laggy | 0.0% | 0.9% |
| Payment and UPI failures | 0.0% | 1.4% |
Share of each category's storefront reviews that describe each kind of malfunction.
Login and OTP failures run at 3.7 times the average, second only to banking. Wrong or stale data runs at 3.7 times as well: records, documents or statuses that don't match what the user expects.
What the storefronts showed
| App | Rating | Reviews read | Malfunction reviews | Main problem |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NextGen mParivahan | 3.7★ | 18 | 7 | Login and OTP |
| UMANG | 4.5★ | 18 | 6 | Login and OTP |
| DigiLocker | 4.2★ | 18 | 5 | Wrong or stale data |
| Aarogya Setu | 4.0★ | 18 | 4 | A feature doesn't work |
| Aadhaar (UIDAI) | 4.2★ | 18 | 3 | Login and OTP |
| DigiYatra | 4.0★ | 9 | 3 | Crashes, won't open |
| ABHA | 4.5★ | 18 | 2 | A feature doesn't work |
| Sanchar Saathi | 4.5★ | 18 | 1 | A feature doesn't work |
Small samples from one day, and Google changes which reviews it shows: a snapshot, not a verdict. Note that UMANG is rated 4.5★, yet 6 of its 18 storefront reviews describe a malfunction. Star ratings and bug reports often tell different stories.
Why government apps break where they do
Identity is the front door. Many government apps sign people in with an Aadhaar-linked OTP, and some fetch documents from DigiLocker or other systems. Each of those is an outside service, so the app's login depends on SMS delivery, the user's linked mobile number, and the service at the other end. When any link fails, the review says "OTP not coming" or "can't log in".
The users are everyone. Government apps serve people on every kind of phone, in every state and language, many of them first-time smartphone users. Budget phones, older Android versions, weak networks and Hindi or regional-language settings aren't edge cases here. They're the main audience.
Records have to match. "Wrong or stale data" reviews are about a document, a status or a detail that doesn't match the user's record. Testing these flows needs real test records and backend checks, not just the screens.
What to test first in a government service app
- Login, OTP and device binding, including an OTP that arrives late, an OTP on the other SIM of a dual-SIM phone, and the number linked to the user's ID being different from the SIM in the phone. See the OTP login cases.
- Aadhaar OTP and document fetch steps, with the outside service slow or failing. The app should explain what happened and offer a retry, not a blank screen. See the Aadhaar eKYC cases.
- Apps stuck on the splash screen, and the first launch after an update, on budget phones and older Android versions. See the app update cases.
- Hindi and regional languages, including every error and status message, at the largest font size. See the Hindi and regional language cases.
- Weak networks and offline: a form that survives a dropped connection, and a clear message instead of a spinner.
Check your own app
Read the full government services breakdown, or scan your app's reviews with the free Play Store bug scanner. 99tests testers in cities across India run your cases on their own budget and mid-range phones, on their own SIMs, with a verified report in 3 business days, from ₹9,999 + GST.